10 common board reporting issues are relevant here:
1. Do we tend to focus too much on the things which are easy and convenient to measure?
2. Are we measuring the right things?
3. Are those measures linked to strategy and key objectives?
4. Measurement-based targets in KPIs and board reports (chosen for their immutability) can be counterproductive and give false impressions / confidence in performance, safety, etc.
5. Aggregated numbers and conflicting data can hide critical issues / problems.
6. Do key messages get lost in a sea of data / detail? [The length of papers continues to be a problem for many boards!]
7. Benchmarking can be a problem (with a potential to focus on the wrong things and cherry-pick the measures which paint us in the best light).Is there really safety in numbers?
8. Have we fallen into the habit of reporting which produces impressive graphics rather than critical analysis and value? [A challenge to management: can complexity be represented with simplicity?]
9. Scaling matters
10. Do dashboard reports provide meaningful insights or just (more) data?
What your board papers may NOT be telling you?
- The “so what”
- The whole story
- The options, assumptions, limitations and sensitivities
- The unvarnished truth (without bias or spin)
- The good news and the bad news (in a timely way)
- Where and how AI has been used in compiling and interpreting the data
- The insights (that matter, require judgement, drive actions and deliver real outcomes)
- The culture and behavioural issues (including potential psychosocial hazards and any red flags)
- The root causes (rather than the symptoms)
- The next steps (including who’s responsible and when it’s due)
Author’s Note
This post was inspired by a BoardPro webinar titled “Reading between the numbers: The Opportunities and Pitfalls of Scorecards”, expertly presented by Julie Garland McLellan, Annemarie Mora and Roger Chao, and the author acknowledges their work.